What is Carnitine?

Цей контент ще не доступний вашою мовою.

Summary

Optimal Intake (male 85kg/181cm / female 52kg/171cm)

Cognitive optimization male: 1,000-2,000 mg/day with appropriate cofactors
Cognitive optimization female: 500-1,500 mg/day with appropriate cofactors
Energy optimization male: 2,000-3,000 mg/day (standard activity), 3,000-4,000 mg/day (athletic performance)
Energy optimization female: 1,000-2,000 mg/day (standard activity), 2,000-3,000 mg/day (athletic performance)
Optimal blood levels: 30-60 μmol/L (plasma) for general health; athletes may benefit from upper range

Five best animal sources:

Beef steak: 100g provides 95 mg (2,000 mg optimization level reached with 2.1kg)
Lamb: 100g provides 78 mg (2,000 mg optimization level reached with 2.6kg)
Pork: 100g provides 50 mg (2,000 mg optimization level reached with 4kg)
Fish (cod): 100g provides 5-7 mg (2,000 mg optimization level reached with 28.5kg)
Whole milk: 100ml provides 3.3 mg (2,000 mg optimization level reached with 60.6L)

Five best non-animal sources:

Tempeh: 100g provides 0.8 mg (2,000 mg optimization level reached with 250kg - effectively impossible)
Nutritional yeast: 100g provides 0.6 mg (minimal amount, not practical as a source)
Avocado: 100g provides 0.2 mg (minimal amount, not practical as a source)
Mushrooms: 100g provides 0.1 mg (minimal amount, not practical as a source)
Asparagus: 100g provides 0.1 mg (minimal amount, not practical as a source)

Consistent intake required? Yes, for optimal energy metabolism and cognitive function. The body can synthesize some carnitine, but consistent intake from food or supplements ensures optimal tissue levels. This is especially true for athletes, vegetarians/vegans, and those with genetic limitations in synthesis.

Are higher doses dangerous? Generally considered safe up to 4,000 mg/day for most adults. Higher doses (>5,000 mg) may cause digestive discomfort, nausea, or diarrhea in some individuals. No established upper limit, but caution is advised above 4,000 mg daily without medical supervision.

Optimal timing for intake:

With meals: Take with food to improve absorption and reduce potential digestive discomfort
Pre-workout: 1,000-2,000 mg 60-90 minutes before exercise can enhance fat utilization and energy production
Split dosing: For higher doses, divide into 2-3 servings throughout the day
Consistency: Daily intake is more important than specific timing for maintaining tissue levels

Introduction

Carnitine is a quaternary ammonium compound that plays a crucial role in energy metabolism. Though often called a vitamin-like compound, it’s more accurately described as a conditionally essential nutrient, as the body can synthesize it from the amino acids lysine and methionine with vitamin C, iron, vitamin B6, and niacin as cofactors.

Carnitine exists in several forms:

L-Carnitine: The biologically active form found naturally in the body and foods
Acetyl-L-Carnitine (ALCAR): A more bioavailable form that readily crosses the blood-brain barrier
Propionyl-L-Carnitine: A form that may have additional cardiovascular benefits
D-Carnitine: An unnatural form that can interfere with L-carnitine utilization and should be avoided

The primary function of carnitine is to transport long-chain fatty acids into mitochondria, where they are oxidized (“burned”) to produce energy. Without adequate carnitine, cells cannot efficiently use fat for energy, leading to potential metabolic issues and energy deficits.

According to experts like Dr. Paul Saladino and Dr. Shawn Baker, carnivore diet proponents, carnitine is one of the most important nutrients for energy metabolism that is predominantly found in animal foods. Dr. Huberman has discussed its potential cognitive benefits, particularly when used in the acetylated form (ALCAR), noting its ability to support brain energy metabolism and possibly enhance neurotransmitter production.

Effects at Different Carnitine Levels

Optimal Levels

Efficient fat metabolism and energy production
Enhanced exercise performance and stamina
Improved recovery after intense exercise
Optimal mitochondrial function
Healthy glucose metabolism
Mental clarity and cognitive function
Reduced exercise-induced muscle damage
Balanced inflammatory response
Proper detoxification of certain metabolic byproducts
Support for cardiovascular function
Enhanced insulin sensitivity
Optimal muscle/fat ratio

Deficiency

Reduced capacity for fat oxidation
Decreased energy levels and fatigue
Impaired exercise performance and endurance
Muscle weakness
Increased susceptibility to hypoglycemia during fasting
Mild cognitive difficulties
Slower recovery from exercise
Reduced metabolic flexibility
Mild cardiovascular strain
Increased fat storage due to impaired utilization

Severe Deficiency

Primary carnitine deficiency (genetic disorder)
Severe fatigue and weakness
Cardiomyopathy
Hypoglycemia
Liver dysfunction
Muscle wasting and weakness
Encephalopathy
Developmental delays (in children)
Metabolic crisis during fasting or illness
Significant impairment in fat metabolism

Excess (Rare)

Gastrointestinal discomfort
Nausea and vomiting
Diarrhea
Fishy body odor
Abdominal cramps
Potential disruption of thyroid hormone function at very high doses
Rare risk of seizures in individuals with seizure disorders

Recommended Dosage

Carnitine intake is measured in milligrams (mg).

General Recommendations

By Age Group

Age Group	AI (mg/day)
Infants (0-12 months)	10
Children (1-3 years)	20
Children (4-8 years)	30-40
Children (9-13 years)	50-100
Adolescents (14-18 years)	100-300
Adults (19+ years)	300-500*
Pregnancy	500
Lactation	500

*Note: These are Adequate Intake (AI) estimates. No formal RDA exists for carnitine as it is considered conditionally essential. The body can synthesize approximately 20-200 mg per day in healthy individuals.

For Specific Body Types

Male (85kg, 181cm)

Baseline intake: 500 mg/day
Adjusted for standard activity: 1,000-2,000 mg/day
Adjusted for athletic performance: 2,000-4,000 mg/day
For cognitive optimization (Huberman protocol): 1,000-2,000 mg/day (preferably as ALCAR)

Female (52kg, 171cm)

Baseline intake: 300-500 mg/day
Adjusted for standard activity: 500-1,000 mg/day
Adjusted for athletic performance: 1,000-3,000 mg/day
For cognitive optimization (Huberman protocol): 500-1,500 mg/day (preferably as ALCAR)

Most healthy omnivorous individuals consuming regular amounts of meat will naturally obtain 100-300 mg of carnitine daily from food. However, athletes, those on plant-based diets, and individuals with certain health conditions may benefit from higher intakes through supplementation. Dr. Saladino has noted that individuals on a carnivore diet likely achieve optimal carnitine status naturally through their high meat intake.

Safe Upper Limits & Toxicity

Maximum Safe Dosage

No official Upper Limit (UL) has been established for carnitine by major regulatory bodies. Research suggests:

Generally recognized as safe (GRAS): Up to 4,000 mg/day
Research protocols have used: Up to 6,000 mg/day without significant adverse effects in healthy individuals
Clinical treatments: Up to 4,000 mg/day for various metabolic conditions

For Specific Body Types

Male (85kg, 181cm)

Practical upper limit: 4,000 mg/day
Higher intakes may be tolerated but offer diminishing returns
Digestive discomfort more likely above this threshold

Female (52kg, 171cm)

Practical upper limit: 3,000-4,000 mg/day
Smaller body mass may warrant slightly lower maximum doses
Individualized tolerance should be assessed

As Dr. Rhonda Patrick has noted, while carnitine is generally well-tolerated, excessively high doses are unlikely to provide additional benefits beyond those seen at more moderate supplementation levels.

Dangerous Dose Levels

Acute toxicity: No established toxic threshold; extremely high doses may cause severe digestive distress
Chronic toxicity: Concerns exist about very high, long-term supplementation potentially altering gut microbiome and TMAO production
Blood levels: No established dangerous threshold; monitoring not typically necessary for supplementation within recommended ranges

Signs of Carnitine Excess

Symptoms of excessive carnitine intake may include:

Nausea and vomiting
Diarrhea
Abdominal cramps
Fishy body odor
Headache
Potential for disrupted thyroid function at very high doses
Possible increased TMAO production (a compound associated with cardiovascular risk)

Health Effects and Benefits

Energy Metabolism

Primary role in transporting fatty acids into mitochondria for energy production
Enables efficient utilization of fat as fuel
Improves metabolic flexibility (switching between fuel sources)
Enhances ATP production and overall energy levels
Supports cellular energy during fasting or low-carbohydrate states
Helps maintain stable energy levels during extended exercise
May improve perceived energy and reduce fatigue
Supports mitochondrial health and function

Exercise Performance

Increases fat oxidation and spares glycogen during exercise
May enhance endurance performance
Reduces exercise-induced muscle damage
Accelerates recovery between training sessions
May improve peak power output in certain activities
Reduces post-exercise muscle soreness
Supports training adaptations
May enhance exercise capacity in deconditioned individuals

Cognitive Function

Acetyl-L-Carnitine readily crosses the blood-brain barrier
Supports brain energy metabolism
May enhance acetylcholine production (important for memory)
Shows neuroprotective properties
Supports mitochondrial function in neurons
May improve mental clarity and cognitive processing
Has shown benefits for age-related cognitive decline
Potential support for focus and attention

Cardiovascular Health

Supports heart muscle energy production
May improve exercise tolerance in heart conditions
Potential to support healthy blood pressure
May improve peripheral circulation
Supports endothelial function
Helps maintain healthy lipid metabolism
May reduce oxidative stress in cardiovascular tissues
Supports overall cardiac energy efficiency

Metabolic Health

Enhances insulin sensitivity
Supports healthy glucose metabolism
May improve body composition
Helps maintain metabolic flexibility
Supports liver function and fat metabolism
May reduce markers of metabolic syndrome
Assists in managing metabolic inefficiencies
Supports thyroid hormone conversion

Deficiency Symptoms

Carnitine deficiency can cause:

Fatigue and low energy
Muscle weakness
Poor exercise tolerance
Increased susceptibility to hypoglycemia during fasting
Brain fog and impaired cognition
Poor fat metabolism
Elevated liver enzymes
Reduced cardiac function
Impaired ketone production during fasting/ketogenic diet
Poor recovery from exercise
Lipid metabolism abnormalities
Intolerance to high-fat meals
Compromised immune function
Reduced ability to maintain body temperature in cold
Impaired fasting tolerance
Increased body fat despite caloric control
Cardiomyopathy (in severe cases)

Primary carnitine deficiency is rare and typically genetic, while secondary deficiencies can occur due to conditions like liver or kidney disease, certain medications, extreme diets, or increased demand (pregnancy, intense exercise).

Sources of Carnitine

Food Sources with Amounts to Meet Requirements

Animal Sources

Food	Serving Size	Carnitine Content (mg)	Amount to Reach 2,000 mg	Amount to Reach 4,000 mg
Beef steak	100g	95	2.1kg	4.2kg
Ground beef	100g	94	2.1kg	4.3kg
Lamb	100g	78	2.6kg	5.1kg
Pork	100g	50	4kg	8kg
Venison	100g	76	2.6kg	5.3kg
Bison/Buffalo	100g	82	2.4kg	4.9kg
Goat	100g	56	3.6kg	7.1kg
Rabbit	100g	48	4.2kg	8.3kg
Chicken breast	100g	9	22.2kg	44.4kg
Turkey	100g	9.5	21.1kg	42.1kg
Fish (cod)	100g	5-7	28.5-40kg	57-80kg
Whole milk	100ml	3.3	60.6L	121.2L
Cheese (cheddar)	100g	3.5	57.1kg	114.3kg
Egg	1 large	0.8	2,500 eggs	5,000 eggs

Plant Sources

Food	Serving Size	Carnitine Content (mg)	Amount to Reach 2,000 mg	Amount to Reach 4,000 mg
Tempeh	100g	0.8	250kg	500kg
Wheat bread	100g	0.4	500kg	1,000kg
Asparagus	100g	0.1	2,000kg	4,000kg
Avocado	100g	0.2	1,000kg	2,000kg
Peanut butter	100g	0.2	1,000kg	2,000kg
Rice	100g	0.3	667kg	1,333kg
Nutritional yeast	100g	0.6	333kg	667kg
Mushrooms	100g	0.1	2,000kg	4,000kg

*Note: Carnitine content can vary based on specific cuts, cooking methods, animal feed, and growing conditions. These values are averages. As evident from the data, plant foods contain negligible amounts of carnitine, making them impractical sources for meeting optimal levels.

Supplements

Types of Carnitine Supplements

L-Carnitine: The standard form, good for general supplementation and energy metabolism
Acetyl-L-Carnitine (ALCAR): More efficiently crosses the blood-brain barrier; preferred for cognitive benefits
L-Carnitine L-Tartrate (LCLT): Rapidly absorbed form; preferred for exercise performance and recovery
Propionyl-L-Carnitine: May provide additional benefits for cardiovascular health and circulation
Glycine Propionyl-L-Carnitine (GPLC): Combines carnitine with glycine; may enhance blood flow and exercise performance
Liquid Carnitine: Faster absorption, good option for those who can’t swallow pills
Carnitine Fumarate: Combined with fumaric acid; may support mitochondrial energy production

Considerations When Choosing Supplements

Form: Select based on primary goal (ALCAR for brain, LCLT for exercise, standard L-carnitine for general use)
Purity: Choose products free from unnecessary fillers and artificial ingredients
Third-party testing: Look for verification of content and purity
Dosage: Typically 500-2,000 mg per serving
Timing: Consider split dosing for larger amounts
Stability: Properly stored in cool, dry place
Synergistic ingredients: Some formulations include complementary nutrients like alpha-lipoic acid
Value: Cost per effective dose can vary widely

Dr. Huberman has specifically mentioned ALCAR (Acetyl-L-Carnitine) for cognitive enhancement protocols, while Dr. Saladino has discussed standard L-carnitine for its metabolic benefits, particularly for individuals who don’t consume sufficient animal products.

Carnitine Optimization Strategies

Absorption Enhancement

Take with meals: Enhances absorption and reduces potential GI discomfort
Carbohydrate timing: Small amount of carbs may improve uptake via insulin response
Avoid excessive fiber: Very high fiber intake at the same time may reduce absorption
Micronutrient support: Ensure adequate vitamin C, B6, and iron for endogenous synthesis
Split dosing: Dividing larger doses throughout the day enhances absorption efficiency
Avoid high-dose mineral supplements: Taking at the same time may interfere with absorption
Choline complementarity: Adequate choline intake may support carnitine utilization

Dietary Strategies

Prioritize ruminant meats: Beef, lamb, and bison provide the highest carnitine concentrations
Regular intake: Consistent consumption of animal products ensures steady carnitine levels
Nose-to-tail eating: Organ meats like heart provide additional carnitine
Grass-fed emphasis: May contain higher levels than grain-fed counterparts
Cooking consideration: Minimize overcooking to preserve carnitine content
Complementary nutrients: Include foods rich in lysine, methionine, vitamin C, iron, and B vitamins
Plant-based consideration: Vegans/vegetarians should strongly consider supplementation
Carnivore advantage: As emphasized by Dr. Baker, a carnivore diet naturally provides substantial carnitine

Supplement Strategies for Optimal Energy

Pre-workout timing: 1,000-2,000 mg approximately 60-90 minutes before exercise
Split protocol: Divide daily intake into 2-3 doses for sustained tissue levels
Form selection: L-Carnitine L-Tartrate may be superior for exercise-specific benefits
Stacking approach: Combine with complementary nutrients like alpha-lipoic acid and CoQ10
Cycling strategy: Some practitioners recommend 12 weeks on, 4 weeks off for optimal response
Loading phase: Higher doses (3,000-4,000 mg) for 1-2 weeks to increase tissue saturation
Maintenance phase: Lower doses (1,000-2,000 mg) for ongoing support
Testing protocol: Consider periodic bloodwork to assess carnitine status if accessible

Synergistic Nutrients

Alpha-Lipoic Acid: Improves mitochondrial function alongside carnitine
Coenzyme Q10: Supports electron transport chain for ATP production
B vitamins: Essential cofactors for energy metabolism, particularly B6
Magnesium: Supports enzymatic reactions involved in energy production
Vitamin C: Required for carnitine synthesis
Creatine: Complementary energy system support
Ribose: Precursor for ATP synthesis
Omega-3 fatty acids: May enhance cellular uptake of carnitine
Zinc: Supports overall metabolic function and hormonal health
Chromium: Helps optimize insulin function for carnitine transport

Special Considerations

Pregnancy and Breastfeeding

Carnitine demands increase during pregnancy
Maternal carnitine levels naturally decrease during pregnancy
Supplementation may be beneficial, particularly for vegetarian/vegan mothers
Recommended intake of 500 mg daily is considered safe
Consultation with healthcare provider essential before supplementation
Breastfeeding transfers carnitine to the infant, maintaining maternal intake is important
No evidence of adverse effects at moderate supplementation levels
May support maternal energy levels during demanding perinatal period

Medical Conditions Affecting Carnitine

Kidney disease: May affect carnitine excretion and synthesis
Liver disease: Can impair carnitine synthesis
Diabetes: May alter carnitine metabolism and increase requirements
Cardiovascular disease: May benefit from supportive carnitine supplementation
Neurodegenerative conditions: Acetyl-L-Carnitine shows particular promise
Hypothyroidism: May affect carnitine metabolism
Seizure disorders: Caution advised with high-dose supplementation
Inflammatory bowel disease: May affect absorption
Certain genetic disorders: Can significantly impair carnitine metabolism
Cancer treatments: May deplete carnitine or alter metabolism

Medication Interactions

Anticonvulsants: May reduce carnitine levels
Valproic acid: Known to deplete carnitine
Antibiotics (pivampicillin, pivmecillinam): May reduce carnitine levels
Certain chemotherapy drugs: Can affect carnitine metabolism
AZT (HIV medication): May deplete carnitine
Thyroid medications: Potential interactions at absorption level
Isotretinoin: May affect carnitine metabolism
Statins: Combination may provide synergistic benefits for some
Blood thinners: Monitor for potential interactions
L-Dopa: ALCAR may enhance effectiveness

Personalized Recommendations

For Male (85kg, 181cm)

Standard intake: 500-1,000 mg L-carnitine daily for general health
Athletic performance: 2,000-3,000 mg L-carnitine L-tartrate, split into 2-3 doses
Cognitive support: 1,000-2,000 mg Acetyl-L-Carnitine, prioritizing morning dosing
Diet focus: Include 150-200g of red meat daily as a baseline source
Timing strategy: 1,000-1,500 mg 60-90 minutes pre-workout on training days
Recovery emphasis: 1,000 mg post-workout may enhance recovery processes
Complementary nutrients: Stack with 100-200 mg CoQ10 and 300-600 mg alpha-lipoic acid
Testing recommendation: Consider RBC carnitine assessment if accessible, particularly if symptoms persist despite supplementation
Metabolic efficiency: Higher doses (3,000-4,000 mg) may benefit those with compromised metabolic function
Dosing schedule: Morning and pre-workout doses typically most effective

For Female (52kg, 171cm)

Standard intake: 300-500 mg L-carnitine daily for general health
Athletic performance: 1,000-2,000 mg L-carnitine L-tartrate, split into 2 doses
Cognitive support: 500-1,000 mg Acetyl-L-Carnitine, prioritizing morning dosing
Diet focus: Include 100-150g of red meat daily as a baseline source
Timing strategy: 500-1,000 mg 60-90 minutes pre-workout on training days
Recovery emphasis: 500-750 mg post-workout for recovery support
Complementary nutrients: Stack with 60-100 mg CoQ10 and 200-400 mg alpha-lipoic acid
Cycle-specific: May benefit from slightly higher doses during luteal phase of menstrual cycle
Pregnancy consideration: Increase to 500 mg daily if planning pregnancy or pregnant
Dosing schedule: Morning and pre-workout doses typically most effective

Activity-Level Adjustments

Sedentary: Baseline intake sufficient (300-500 mg)
Moderately Active: Increase by 200-500 mg/day
Athletic/Regular Training: Increase by 500-1,000 mg/day
Competitive/Intense Training: Increase by 1,000-2,000 mg/day
Metabolic Challenges: Consider increases of 500-1,000 mg/day
Plant-Based Diets: Additional 500-1,000 mg/day recommended
Aging (65+): Consider 10-20% increase over baseline recommendations
Recovery Phases: Emphasize consistent intake rather than higher acute doses

Carnitine for Cognitive Performance

Current Research Highlights

Acetyl-L-Carnitine (ALCAR) crosses the blood-brain barrier effectively
May support acetylcholine synthesis and neurotransmitter function
Shows neuroprotective effects in research models
Potentially enhances mitochondrial function in brain cells
Research indicates potential benefits for age-related cognitive decline
May support focus, attention, and mental energy
Preliminary evidence suggests potential mood-stabilizing properties
Supports brain metabolism, particularly during fasting or ketogenic states
May enhance neuroplasticity and learning processes
Shows promise for stress resilience and cognitive protection during high demand

Implementation Strategies

Prioritize ALCAR form: Most research shows superior brain bioavailability
Dosage range: 500-2,000 mg daily based on body size and response
Morning protocol: Taking with breakfast may enhance daytime cognitive benefits
Stack with choline: Alpha-GPC or CDP-choline may have synergistic effects
Cycle approach: 8-12 weeks on, 2-4 weeks off may optimize receptor sensitivity
Combine with DHA: Omega-3 fatty acids may enhance neuronal membrane effects
Include B vitamins: Particularly B1, B5, and B12 for complementary brain energy support
Monitor subjective effects: Track cognitive performance, mood, and mental clarity
Pre-cognitive demand dosing: Additional dose before mentally demanding tasks

Carnitine for Energy Production

Metabolic Mechanisms

Primary role in transporting long-chain fatty acids into mitochondria
Facilitates beta-oxidation of fatty acids for ATP production
Enhances metabolic flexibility between fat and carbohydrate utilization
Improves mitochondrial efficiency and function
Helps buffer metabolic byproducts during intense energy production
Supports glucose utilization and glycogen sparing during exercise
Enhances oxygen utilization efficiency
May improve subjective energy and reduce fatigue perception
Supports ATP regeneration between high-intensity efforts
Helps maintain cellular energy homeostasis under stress

Implementation Strategies

Choose L-Carnitine L-Tartrate: Generally superior for performance applications
Timing strategy: 60-90 minutes pre-workout maximizes availability
Carbohydrate co-ingestion: Small amount of carbs (20-30g) may enhance uptake
Loading approach: Higher doses (3,000-4,000 mg) for 1-2 weeks may enhance tissue saturation
Maintenance phase: 1,000-2,000 mg daily to maintain levels
Split protocol: Divide daily doses to maintain steady blood levels
Intra-workout consideration: For sessions longer than 90 minutes, additional 500-1,000 mg may be beneficial
Post-workout recovery: Additional dose may enhance recovery processes
Concurrent training support: Higher doses may benefit those performing both strength and endurance training

Expert Insights

Dr. Huberman discusses carnitine’s role in supporting brain energy metabolism and potential cognitive enhancement
Dr. Rhonda Patrick highlights its crucial function in mitochondrial fatty acid oxidation
Dr. Paul Saladino emphasizes its natural abundance in red meat and the importance for those limiting animal food intake
Dr. Shawn Baker notes that carnivore dieters rarely need supplementation due to high intake from meat
Research suggests that tissue saturation may take 3-4 weeks of consistent supplementation
Studies indicate potentially greater benefits in vegetarians/vegans and older adults
Performance research shows most significant effects in metabolically demanding activities
Emerging research suggests potential applications for metabolic health optimization

Summary

Carnitine is a conditionally essential nutrient critical for energy metabolism, particularly fat utilization. It plays essential roles in mitochondrial function, exercise performance, cognitive health, and metabolic efficiency.

Getting Enough: For most people, this means regular consumption of animal foods (especially red meat) or supplementation for those limiting animal products
Avoiding Excess: While generally safe, stay below 4,000 mg/day unless medically supervised
Best Approach: Consistent intake through diet and targeted supplementation based on activity level and goals
Form Matters: Choose L-Carnitine for general use, L-Carnitine L-Tartrate for exercise, and Acetyl-L-Carnitine for cognitive benefits
Energy Optimization: Focus on pre-workout timing, adequate dosing (2,000-3,000 mg for active individuals), and complementary nutrients
Cognitive Enhancement: Emphasize Acetyl-L-Carnitine form, morning dosing, and consistent intake
Synergistic Strategy: Combine with alpha-lipoic acid, CoQ10, ribose, and B vitamins for enhanced mitochondrial support

Remember that individual responses vary based on diet, activity level, genetic factors, and overall health status. Those with existing medical conditions or taking medications should consult healthcare providers before beginning high-dose supplementation.